More Perfect than the Moon (Sarah, Plain and Tall, 4)
#4 of 5 in Sarah, Plain and Tall Series
on Goodreads (2,379)
What’s inside...
Eight-year-old Cassie Witting is upset when she finds out that her mother, Sarah, is expecting a baby, but writing in the journal that belonged to her brother Caleb helps her sort out her feelings and understand that Sarah will always love her. This is the fourth book in the series that began with the Newbery Medal–winning Sarah, Plain and Tall. The beloved story of Sarah, Plain and Tall continues as Cassie is an observer, a writer, a storyteller. And for her, life is as it should be. But change is inevitable, even on the prairie. Something new is expected, and Sarah says it will be the perfect gift. Cassie isn't so sure. But just like life changes, people change too, and Cassie learns that unexpected surprises can bring great joy. More Perfect than the Moon invites us back to the Witting family farm, first visited in the Newbery Medal-winning Sarah, Plain and Tall. With her lyrical prose, Patricia MacLachlan writes about a family's boundless capacity for love.
Discussion points
How do you think Cassie felt when she started writing in her journal? Can you relate to her feelings?
Why do you think it's important for Cassie to keep a journal? What benefits does it bring to her life?
How does Cassie's family react to the changes happening around them? What does that tell us about their family dynamics?
What role does nature play in this story, and how does it affect the characters?
If you were Cassie, how would you handle the changes and challenges she faces?
Tip: Role play these questions
Start by sharing your own thoughts on the book to create an open dialogue. Use the key questions above as a guide, but let the conversation flow naturally based on your child's responses. Show genuine interest in their opinions, and encourage them to elaborate on their thoughts with follow-up questions. Reinforce the connection between the book’s themes and real-life scenarios to make the discussion more relevant and engaging.
Key lessons
Example Lesson: Expression Through Writing
Explanation: The protagonist, Cassie, uses her journal to express her feelings and document her family's experiences, showcasing the power of writing as a tool for self-expression.
Real-World Application: Children can be encouraged to keep a journal or diary to explore their emotions and articulate their daily experiences, promoting emotional literacy and reflective thinking.
Example Lesson: Understanding Change and Growth
Explanation: Cassie deals with significant changes in her family structure, learning to accept and adapt to new family members and dynamics.
Real-World Application: This lesson can help children understand that changes in family and life are normal and can be embraced positively, helping them develop resilience and adaptability.
Example Lesson: Empathy and Compassion
Explanation: Throughout the story, Cassie demonstrates empathy by trying to understand the feelings and perspectives of her family members.
Real-World Application: Children can learn to be more aware of the emotions of others around them, fostering a sense of empathy and strengthening interpersonal relationships.
Example Lesson: The Value of Patience
Explanation: Cassie learns to be patient as she navigates through family changes and awaits the arrival of new siblings.
Real-World Application: This teaches children the importance of patience in achieving understanding and accepting others, crucial skills in social interactions and personal development.
Example Lesson: Importance of Family Bonds
Explanation: The story emphasizes the strength and support that family bonds provide, even when challenged by changes.
Real-World Application: Understanding this lesson can reinforce the concept that maintaining strong family connections is vital, encouraging children to value and nurture their relationships with family members.