Sarah, Plain and Tall
#1 of 5 in Sarah, Plain and Tall Series
on Goodreads (15)
What’s inside...
Sarah, Plain and Tall is a children's book by Patricia MacLachlan that tells the story of a widowed farmer named Jacob Witting living in the late 19th century, who places an advertisement for a wife and mother for his two children, Anna and Caleb. Sarah Wheaton from Maine responds to the ad, describing herself as 'plain and tall.' Sarah travels to the Witting farm to see if she would be a good fit for the family. Over time, Sarah bonds with the children and Jacob, bringing joy and music back into their home. The family faces challenges as they adjust to each other, and Sarah misses her old home by the sea. Ultimately, Sarah decides to stay with the Witting family, finding love and a sense of belonging. The book explores themes of loneliness, change, and the creation of a new family.
Discussion points
How do you think Sarah felt when she decided to move to a new place with the Witting family?
What are some ways Caleb and Anna show their feelings about Sarah coming to live with them?
What do you think makes a place feel like home?
Why do you think Sarah keeps looking at the sea? How is that connected to her feelings?
How does the family change from the beginning to the end of the story?
Tip: Role play these questions
Consider the emotions and motivations of each character as you discuss the story. Encourage your child to relate these to their own experiences of meeting new people or moving to new places.
Discuss the idea of home and family, and how communities can be formed in different ways but still provide love and support.
Use descriptive passages from the book to help your child visualize the scenes and settings, enhancing their understanding and engagement with the story.
Emphasize the growth and change of the characters over time to help your child understand the dynamic nature of relationships and life situations.
Explore the themes of adaptability and courage with your child, discussing how these qualities can be important in their own lives.
Key lessons
Example Lesson: Adaptability and openness to change
Explanation: Sarah comes from a different environment when she moves to live with the Witting family. Throughout 'Sarah, Plain and Tall', Sarah adapts to her new surroundings and the different lifestyle, showing resilience and openness.
Real-World Application: Children learn the importance of embracing new environments and experiences, whether it's moving to a new place, starting a different school or adapting to any new situation.
Example Lesson: Importance of communication
Explanation: The characters in the book frequently express their feelings and concerns, whether it's through letters between Sarah and the children or conversations within the family.
Real-World Application: This teaches children the value of sharing thoughts and emotions with others, which is crucial for building strong relationships and resolving conflicts.
Example Lesson: Understanding and overcoming grief
Explanation: The Witting family, including the children, deal with the loss of their mother. Sarah’s arrival helps them in their healing process, showcasing how people can support each other through difficult times.
Real-World Application: Children learn that grief is a natural response to loss but also see the importance of support from family and friends in overcoming these emotional challenges.
Example Lesson: Significance of family bonds
Explanation: The book highlights the building of a new family unit with Sarah and the deepening connections between her and the children.
Real-World Application: It reinforces the concept that families can be formed in many ways, and that love and care are the most important foundations of family life.